Le§ is More

Music of short duration

In the course of testing the composition systems for hondrd, and while waiting restlessly for the time when “full” length pieces could be produced, I came to enjoy listening to the short, dense, well-shaped pieces that were forthcoming. They come with well-related parts, good internal structure, interesting timbres & rhythms, and are mostly not tedious to listen to. And I began to wonder about the relevance of duration to listening satisfaction.

In the classical canon there have been a few, very brief compositions: Bagatelle 10 from Op.119 of Beethoven is over in about 15 seconds. The kleines Stück 2 from Op.11 of Anton Webern is over in 20 seconds. Many works by Erik Satie are very short, as are some by Béla Bartók. In most cases, the content is very carefully planned to deliver musical ideas with great economy or in great concentration. But I believe that in a concert setting they are liable to remain oddities, since many concert-goers are expecting longer pieces which are perhaps more “serious” or satisfying. Taken as short yet very complete statements, these miniatures should really sit in a space apart, for the contemplation they deserve. And perhaps repeated several times, so we can digest & explore with increasing acuity and appreciation – though perhaps not 840 times as Satie once recommended (for his Vexations of 1894).

Indeed, repeat listening of complex pieces can be very rewarding. There is no chance for boredom to settle, exactly (unless we’ve reached the 841st run), and we gain confidence in entering closer to the composer’s ideas and sound-world. Certainly longer pieces can be challenging, and time-consuming for this kind of study, but short pieces are ideal. We can just loop them. In a reasonable period of time we can come to grasp the music as a whole, something which pieces with long, symphonic development can demand many years of listening & study, in some cases.

Loops, riffs & other primeval algorithms

After listening to new music for the first time, there may be something which sticks in our mind. Never mind the “journey” we underwent for now, moving between musical events in a truly mysterious way. If there is nothing memorable, we may consider the piece has failed in some way. Maybe there was some curiosity aroused, then we may listen again. Sometimes, memory of a certain passage might arise spontaneously minutes or hours later, and we rush back to appreciate the gem and its embedding, in greater depth. Obviously this interesting process is crystallized when the piece is very short. And when the gem we identified is repeated often, we call this a riff. Use of riffs and other musical ideas which are designed (or are discovered) to be memorable, is a common technique of composers, and even musical improvisers. Evocation of memorable musical/sonic events, and repetition, are perhaps the two staples of effective music creation.

Looping is a modern extension of the bars’ repeat :|| where any analog tape or digital audio or MIDI sequence can be repeated to any specification (usually exact copy) and between any two points in the stream. This simple effect can be very powerful, and probably triggers a deep innate response in us. As I suggested in → an essay for Empaθi, you can turn noise into a groove using just a loop. In typical songs, a good groove can propel us through otherwise boring territory.

So take any short & potentially interesting piece of music. Not too short, and not too simple – the ubiquitous “sound bytes” of, for example, TikTok, can be both trivial and tedious (with no blame upon the original composer). Then we may notice, after a couple of plays, something memorable, which acts as a point of seduction or an anchor, which in turn helps to invite closer inspection & intimacy and dozens more listens. Then, perhaps sooner rather than later, we should start to recognize the fine details and subtleties of the composition, secrets the composer wants to impart, things which are not boring even after many listens. Without that hook of memorability, the content can be easy to ignore, the effort of looking for patterns & relationships is too much, things can appear arbitrary and pointless.

Of course other processes can operate to help form a connection with (drawing us into, making us open to) the music – a musician’s reputation, personality or appearance, the track title, its artwork, blurb, interesting lyrics, the listening environment. But that’s another story.

Attention span & satisfying content

Currently, songs in pop music don’t go for much longer than three minutes; shorter than two or longer than four are quite unusual, and sometimes suggest a less or more serious piece, respectively. It seems a rather artificial limit, but it’s at least partly due to the time needed to build and round off a lyric’s storyline, and partly due to an audience’s (presumed) attention span. But it’s still an arbitrary convention when we consider an opera’s libretto can take hours to unfold, much music has no verbal content at all & thus no need to “hear it out”, and attention can be moulded depending on such factors as emotional investment, danceability & curiosity. The sense of a required time for enjoyment of music is perhaps related to our pace of life, and limited available leisure time, and we can feel short-changed if the exposure is too brief, or the content doesn’t bring happiness (for some reason) within that period.

Now there is an interesting option that sits between the easily digested and satisfying loop, and the full-blown song or symphony – and that is the very short piece. What I found when I listened (many times) to the tracks I designed for → Congesta musica, was that it can be a perfectly acceptable musical experience listening to a concentrated one-minute song played (or looped) say 3 times, and indeed could be preferable to playing a more dilute three-minute song once. Many modern pop songs have content which can be quickly absorbed, and a single listening can be enough to judge and/or enjoy them. Played many times however, these initially appealing pieces can quickly become tedious (unless other, social or personal factors come to the rescue). But compare this, for a moment, with the ultra-short pieces by Webern. Russell Platt in The New Yorker 2017 described the composer’s works as “haiku-like in their gnomic concentration”; they are meticulously constructed, with intricate relations and complex play, and are very demanding for listeners. Among other things, Webern was interested in brevity, exploring individual sounds, and the virtuosic possibilities of counterpoint. Some of his pieces are incredibly difficult for human players. He is not popular, but I think his example is very interesting.

Rate of delivery

There are a couple of things that could transform the ideals of Webern into a more approachable form for a modern audience. One is allowing Music to sink back into its abstract home and give some relief to composers and performers – by using computers and algorithms of arbitrary complexity to assist in the design and production of these gnomic musical objects. Otherwise, realizing highly concentrated content is all too difficult. Even Frank Zappa appreciated this when he got his Synclavier and created the award-winning Jazz From Hell in 1986 (which pieces are BTW still very dilute compared to Webern). It’s not a fault that the typical modern song is written on a guitar or piano, and played for the most part by non-virtuosos. But to achieve a greater degree of melodic, harmonic, rhythmic and structural complexity (aka interest) using typical methods and typical forms is problematic, and possibly frustrating. One solution is inclusion of a solo, where a talented instrumentalist inserts a (hopefully) interesting, detailed, inspired section of semi-related music into an otherwise uniform song format. And not saying the newly emerging AI systems are either useful or capable in helping out here, but maybe we should really judge the music on its own terms anyway, and refrain from letting a person’s reputation or looks or stage presence over-shadow what can be shallow, insipid music.

The other thing is to allow such pieces a duration appropriate to their musical density. A riff is probably the smallest unit of useful music, and a very short one may be fascinating, but too brief on its own. A four-second piece containing enormous musical information could be delivering its payload at a rate few listeners could appreciate. But in both cases, looping or frequent repetition enables us to absorb, perhaps subconsciously at first, the embedded content. Another format might be the medley, a collection of very short pieces which almost run together, but can easily withstand multiple listenings due the richness of each “carriage” in the train. (Shameless plug for the album → Congesta musica.) Sure, slowly developing, symphonic style pieces act in a slightly different manner, where details accumulate over time, and their success is based on how well they lead us along, and change us, via subtle musical means. In either the short repetitive case, or the journey style, there is still always the danger of inducing tedium.

Tedium & excess

I have noticed a few kinds of tedium related to new music listening:-
× waiting too long for something interesting, or the promise of such
× boredom with things too familiar or too repetitive
× confusion, waiting for structure to become clearer
× meeting inexplicable events, too surprising or lacking thought
× waiting too long for resolution of harmonic tension
× enduring too many noisey or shrill sounds
× enduring lack of consistent pulse or event timing
× general lack of connection, impatience to reach the end.

Obviously good music will seek to reduce the possibility of tedium, and a genre of music may already include examples their audience half expects to be listenable. But in meeting new music, or seeking to produce something more interesting, finding the right balance between novelty & sameness, easy-going & complex, can be a great challenge. There still needs to be some kind of invitation (hook or gem) with which we can become absorbed in the music, and in turn, expanded by the sonic or abstract world in which the music lives and breathes. As I mentioned, other factors can make objectively ordinary music into an extraordinary experience, we can hum and dance along; but sometimes we are looking for a satisfying adventure.

In the early 1950s, Pierre Boulez (among others, including Webern) experimented with short pieces of Total Serialism, a twelve-tone system with dynamic re-assignment of musical parameters. Going beyond the already exotic and challenging regime of Serialism, he sought freshness & pure adventure in music. I think, with respect, it failed in a couple of ways. First, some spark of familiarity is needed before access and intimacy can occur, and repetition of musical situations is a frankly natural means of lighting this. Constant rug-pulling along the musical journey can be annoying. The other thing is (and this can apply to many atonal styles), we don’t have, or know enough about, absolute pitch semantics. There may have been a sense of this in ancient, mystical India, but most people are aware more of intervals and movement of pitch within a harmonic field, whether that field is clearly defined (as in tonal music) or simply resulting from overlapping pitches. Dynamic application of serial techniques easily disrupts our association with the pitch relationships and timbres already heard. If that is desirable, then OK go for it.

No, no, Mies van der Rohe

Less is more—as a design principle—is often associated with the architect Mies van der Rohe, whose work is epitomized in the steel and glass skyscrapers of New York. He sought elegance, timelessness, and functionality by prioritizing the essential elements of construction (brick, concrete, steel, glass) and of form, and removing superfluous ornamentation. Unfortunately for modern life, adherence to such ideas completely demotes the humanesque elements of comfort, creativity and charm, which we really need more, than a cool ideal which can be grasped in a single glance. Application of the principle of absorptive expansion to such prosaic raw material as rectangle, cement and economics, is almost a form of misconduct. Happily we still have the invisible, sky-bursting power of music of which even the shortest riffs can supply more joy than the longest avenue of sun-glinting office towers.


hondrd@skyknowledge.com
Content © 2023 Ian James