Lieder ohne Worte
Songs without words

Songs with no singer

Music with high density, with many musical ideas presented in a short duration, discussed in the essay → Less is More, and exhibited in the album → Congesta musica, was an essential focus from the beginning, due to one main, perceived disadvantage – lack of a vocalist. Instrumental music, near the mainstream at least, is often felt to be missing a human voice, in spite of whatever talent is evident in the playing or composition. And this is felt acutely when the music is found to be algorithmic, or in some sense artificial in nature.

The title Lieder ohne Worte is borrowed from Felix Mendelssohn, who thus named a collection of short lyrical piano works dated 1829 to 1845. His idea is a kind of precedent for musical works which are relatively simple, but (ideally) have enough interest to compete with full-strength romantic symphonies, and operas with living voices and theatrical intrigue. Since then a few genres of non-orchestral instrumental music have established a reasonable status without needing a singer – Jazz, EDM, Ambient (and there are many traditional non-Western examples which are still somewhat novel for mainstream listeners). Common features of singer-less music include greater interest in rhythm, overall timbre & complexity (which can come from careful design, or from nuances & ornamentations generated by virtuosic players). Yet sometimes songs without words just take a popular instrument to substitute for a vocalist – sax, electric guitar or piano, for example, or for a richer choral effect, a string or brass section. Certainly some of my more successful experiments gained “validity” by having a solo or lead-melodic instrument appearing in this manner.

Stirring & holding interest

This is a challenge for instrumental pieces. Writing for a well-equipped symphony orchestra could allow for great exploration of timbre, dynamics (and acoustics, if live in a great hall). But the modern, mainstream ensemble has only a few players with very familiar instruments, and must make do with “effects” pedals and/or synths with weird settings to achieve interesting or uncommon timbres. Progressive and jazz style music can also add excitement through complex rhythm and harmonies. Having a human singer singing engaging lyrics is much less of a challenge for the presenter of a piece, when the “backing” may even be minimal or unsophisticated.

In theory, from a (somewhat abstract) musical perspective, it shouldn’t matter what instruments are used, whether orchestral, electrified, digital, hi-fi or lo-fi, if the combinations—timbres—achieved are good, and especially where the composer is generating appropriately exciting events. Yet in practice, and from my own (sometimes heartbreaking) experience developing the Dsynth, there needs to be something special about a sound-source coerced to produce a musical note. Basically, there needs to be something natural about it, preferably with as much variety, subtlety and aliveness as a human singing voice. This can be accomplished in many ways, and in a sense, for the sound designer, it can be just like composing the notes they eventually play. As I suggested elsewhere, the sound’s waveform is made up of shapes within shapes, which change over time, whether the scale is microsecond or quarter-note. And as we listen—subconsciously, in the case of individual or complex additions of waveforms—we may become engaged in the adventure suggested by the natural diversity and movement of these sonic events. The saddest extreme is the sine wave, a pure electronic tone emanating from the cheapest cheap organ. The other extreme is just this side of the threshold into painful noise. The human voice, and most popular instruments (tested and refined over hundreds of years), are usually satisfactory in this regard. For artificially synthesized instruments, the desired quality is achievable – if we attend to this deeper level of composition.

Physical abstraction

One of the wonders of man-made music is how, on one hand, it has no concrete & lasting form, while on the other, it’s able to stir us to move, dance, hum and sing along with it, to a sometimes joyous degree. There are many depths to the phenomenon of Music (and of Sound in general), of course. But there’s one thing which can de-ephemeralize music, and that is its social aspect. There can be an environment, personalities, opinions, video-clips. In itself, this is a natural and inevitable extension of the musical experience. And yet, music’s power is substantial, and in essence has no need of physical decoration, verbal embellishment, or any conceptual framework. Songs (with words and singer) are a wonderful collaboration of music and literature, but consider how the very best songs often rely on, or shine with, attention given to the musical details – a chest note, a resonant vowel, a tremble, accents, a slide, a gasp, which often take inspiration and cues from the phonological and semantic elements of the lyrics, and indeed could just as easily have been scored that way.

It is because of the abstract nature of music, I think, that we may quite easily step back from the “mundane” aspects (such as danceability, singer’s hairstyle, album cover, chart position) and attend to the almost metaphysical aspects which we cannot exactly describe, but which still entice & massage our musical senses. For this reason, it is clearly possible for any sound-source, whether human voice, or stretched & vibrating thing, or digitally encoded speaker-cone sequence, to create satisfactory music. And even this latter source, the most unnatural in its description, can become alive, musically, either by human design, or by human design’s design (AI). It points to a more abstract, perhaps purer approach to creating and listening to music, where humans—even though it all starts with us—can be kinda secondary. A bit like modern Mathematics or Cosmology, in the sense of What else awaits us?


hondrd@skyknowledge.com
Content © 2023 Ian James